skip to main content

2015 STS Making and Doing Program

Meeting Home | Making & Doing Main | Making and Doing 2015 | Category: Design and Planning

How’s My Feedback?

Ziewitz, Malte, Cornell University

Co-Authors:

Steve Woolgar, Linköping University
Chris Sugden, University of Oxford

How’s My Feedback?” was a collaborative design experiment to rethink and evaluate web-based review, rating, and ranking schemes. Responding to widespread concerns about the social implications of public feedback platforms in the style of TripAdvisor, Yelp, or Amazon reviews, this project set out to turn the rationale of public assessment on itself. Specifically, we brought together makers, operators, regulators, and users of these schemes in two design workshops and a conference. Together, we developed and prototyped a website that allows users publicly to rate their experience with review and rating schemes – a feedback website for feedback websites. The ESRC-funded initiative allowed us to consider some key questions at the intersection of STS, design, and engagement: what happens when evaluators are asked to evaluate their own activities? How far can critical reflexivity and provocation take us? How to walk the fine line between sustaining and subverting a rationale of regulation?

Conference report: http://www.howsmyfeedback.org/project/the-hows-my-feedback-conference-a-recap/

Link to project: www.howsmyfeedback.org

Comments

  • LinkedIn

Barbosa e Silva: STS ‘Making’ and ‘Knowings’

Battles: Lightbox: Art|Information

Clement: Mapping Internet Surveillance

Collier: The SERRC

Comisso: Scientific Legislation

Cross: Off The Grid

de la Torre: STS+ With Practitioners

Forlano: Reimagining Work

Gardner: Body Editing

Gruber: Making Mirror Neurons

Hamilton: The Anarchy of the Imagination

Hermans: rePlay: De-commodifying Music

Hosman: Solar Digital Libraries

Iles: Greening Chemistry

Irani: Matters of Care in Crowdsourcing

Jain: Things that Art

Klein: Experimental Methods

Lakoff: Limn: An Experimental Scholarly Magazine

Lee : Teaching Sewol Disaster

Liboiron: Civic Laboratory: Plastics

Lie: Film: Medical Imaging

Loukissas: Life and Death of Data

Lucena: CSR & Social Justice

Miller: The Shore Line

Morales-Nasser: STS and ART

Myers: The Write2Know Project

Nieusma: STS Design Program

Ostman: Nano & Society

Ostrowski: Empirical Prints

Peek: Making Machines that Make

Poirier: Cyberinfrastructure for STS

Quitmeyer: Mobile Wilderness Making

Richardson: Critical Digital Exhibits

Riley: Doing Engineering Justice

Rogers: Making Science Visible

Sabanovic: A Human-Centered Robotics Curriculum

Schwartz-Marin: Citizen-Led Forensics

Selin: Futurescape City Tours

Shrum: Light Years

Smiley: ‘zines as method

Southwick: BlackBox Vending Machine

Stettler: Can Innovators Be Made?

Taylor: Connecting-Probing-Reflecting Spaces

Vidart-Delgado : Department of Play

Visperas: Thinking with Catalyst

Wang: Wooden Boat Building

Warren: Crafting Digital Stories

Watts: The Energy Walk

Whynacht: The Now(here) Project

Woelfle-Erskine: Tell a Salmon

Ziewitz: How’s My Feedback?

Zuiderent-Jerak: Situated Intervention